Last updated:

Most barrier arguments start in the wrong place. A buyer picks a film, then asks what shelf life it delivers. The answer is unknowable, because the film was never the input — the product was. The barrier requirement is a property of what you are packing, how much of it, and how long it has to last. The film is the last decision, not the first.

This page is about setting that requirement. It does not give you a threshold, and the reason is set out below.

Four inputs, before any film is discussed

  1. What fails. Oxidation, moisture pick-up, aroma loss, light-driven color change, or a combination. Each one is governed by a different number, and a film good at one can be mediocre at another.
  2. How much change is acceptable. Not “as little as possible” — a measurable limit. A trained sensory panel detecting rancidity, a moisture content that makes a powder cake, a color reading. If this is undefined, no barrier figure can be judged right or wrong.
  3. How much surface area per unit of product. This is the input most often skipped, and it moves the requirement more than anything else on this list.
  4. The life and the conditions. Target shelf life, storage temperature, humidity, and the distribution the pack survives on the way there.

Why the area-to-mass ratio decides more than the film does

Ingress scales with the area of film exposed. Damage to the product scales with the mass inside. So the number that actually matters is area per unit mass — and it changes fast with pack format.

Take the same film and the same product. A 20 g sachet has a far higher surface area per gram than a 2 kg bag: more film per unit of product, so more ingress per unit of product, so a tighter barrier is needed to reach the same shelf life. Halve the fill in the same bag and the area per unit mass doubles, so the transmission you can tolerate halves. Scale the pack down and keep its shape, and the ratio moves more slowly, because surface area falls with roughly the two-thirds power of mass — but a hundredfold drop in fill weight still multiplies the area per unit mass by about five. Nothing about the film changed. Only the pack did.

This is why a threshold table would be worse than useless. Any figure published for “coffee” or “snacks” is really a figure for one fill weight, one format and one shelf life, and it will be wrong by a large factor for the next job that reads it. We would rather hand you the calculation than a number that quietly fails.

Three failure modes, three different numbers — and one gap

What goes wrongThe number that governs itWhat it does not tell you
Oxidation, rancidity, vitamin lossOTR — cm³/(m²·24 h)Nothing about moisture
Caking, softening, crisp lossWVTR — g/(m²·24 h)Nothing about oxygen
Fading, light-driven off-flavorsOptical density or light transmissionNothing about either permeant
Aroma and odor transferNeither — and this is the gapOxygen and moisture figures are silent here

That last row matters more than it looks. A pack can hit its OTR and WVTR targets and still lose its aroma profile, because the permeants that carry flavor compounds are not the two the industry measures. If aroma retention is the actual requirement, say so — the answer may be a different structure rather than a tighter version of the same one.

Bands you will see quoted, and what they are worth

Supplier literature often bands barrier levels something like this: high barrier from roughly 0.1 to 1, medium from 1 to 50, low above 50, in cm³/(m²·24 h) for oxygen and g/(m²·24 h) for water vapor. These bands circulate widely and are useful as a way of talking, but no standards body defines them, and they say nothing about whether a given band suits your product. Treat them as vocabulary, not as a specification.

Flat film data is not the figure in the pack

Every barrier number on a datasheet is measured on a flat, conditioned sample. A finished pouch is folded, gusseted, sealed, filled and dropped. Three things consume the difference:

  • Corners and gussets. The film stretches at the base folds of a stand-up pouch, so the barrier thins exactly where the pack is handled most. A structure that passes on flat film can still fail at the gusset.
  • Flex-cracking and pinholes. A deposited metal layer is the most sensitive part of the structure to repeated flexing, and the least forgiving of a filler that drops product in from height.
  • Seals and contamination. A seal that carries product in the seal area is a leak path that no OTR figure describes.

The practical consequence: build margin into the target. If the calculation says you need 2 cm³/(m²·24 h), specifying a film that measures exactly 2 cm³/(m²·24 h) leaves nothing for the pack to lose in conversion and filling.

How to compare the numbers you are quoted

Four lines decide whether two figures can be compared at all: the method, the temperature, the relative humidity and the unit. Ours are oxygen by GB/T 19789, the coulometric method, and water vapor by GB/T 26253-2010, the infrared method — a modified adoption of ISO 15106-2 — reported in cm³/(m²·24 h) and g/(m²·24 h), at the temperature and humidity recorded on our test reports. Those fall within 21–30 °C and 40–70 % relative humidity, and a figure taken at 38 °C and 90 % RH is a different measurement of the same film.

Two further habits are worth having. Ask for a ceiling rather than an average: “below 1 cm³/(m²·24 h)” holds for every roll, “typically 1” is not. And ask what the weakest point of the structure is, because barrier is set by the worst layer, the worst seal and the worst fold, not by the best measurement.

Where our two grades sit against a requirement

Once the requirement is written down, the film choice is usually quick. Our standard metallized PE is an inner sealing web that also blocks light and gives moderate moisture resistance — WVTR 2.1 g/(m²·24 h) at 40 µm — with no oxygen barrier to speak of. It fits packs where the requirement is light protection plus ordinary moisture resistance and the ply has to seal. See how the two grades differ.

Our high-barrier grade is the opposite construction: oxygen and moisture both below 1 — cm³/(m²·24 h) for oxygen and g/(m²·24 h) for water vapor — light blocking from the aluminium, and no seal of its own, which puts it in the middle of a three-ply PE structure. Whatever figure a supplier publishes, the limits of a barrier number are worth reading before you write one into a specification. The high-barrier grade’s specification is set out separately. If the calculation lands between the two, the honest answer is usually that the pack needs a different structure rather than a film that does not exist.

What to send us

Send the four inputs — what fails, the acceptable limit, the fill weight and format, and the target life with its storage conditions. With those we will tell you which grade can meet the target, where the pack will lose barrier in conversion, and if the target is beyond what a film can deliver, we will say that rather than quote around it. Send us the four inputs and we will come back with a structure, not a datasheet.

Questions buyers ask about barrier targets

What OTR do I need for coffee?

There is no single figure, and any supplier who gives you one is quoting their own fill weight and format rather than yours. Coffee fails by oxidation and by aroma loss, and the requirement moves with the pack: a 250 g valve bag and a 1 kg block bottom bag do not need the same barrier. Give us the fill weight, the target shelf life and the storage conditions, and the answer becomes a calculation.

Is a lower OTR always better?

No. Lower OTR costs more, and past a point the weak point of the pack stops being the film and becomes the seal, the gusset or the closure. Barrier beyond what the rest of the structure can hold is money spent on a number rather than on shelf life.

Can I use flat film data for a finished pouch?

Not directly. Datasheet figures are measured on a flat, conditioned sample; a pouch is folded, gusseted, sealed, filled and dropped, and each of those steps removes some of the barrier the flat film measured. Use the flat figure to choose between films, then build margin into the target for what conversion and filling will take away.

Because a table would be wrong for most of the people reading it. Transmission scales with film area while damage scales with product mass, so the requirement depends on fill weight and pack format as much as on the product. A table is a figure for one job presented as a rule for all of them.